Do you ever wonder what a professional editor is looking for when they’re reading your writing? The best editors are worried about you and what they need to do to make you look stunning.
But editors aren’t fairy tale magicians. They can’t transform your rotting pumpkins into royal stage coached. The harder you make them work, the less likely they are to want to work with you again.
We want to give you a peek inside the mind of a good macroeditor and the everyday battles.
Wait. What’s a macroeditor?
That’s the person who handles the big picture of your manuscript. These editorial brilliants fly at 30,000, 20,000, even 10,000 feet, and attempt to avoid the brambles and weeds of the microeditor (also known as the copyeditor or grammar police). Impressing them is easier than you think.
Here are 5 simple writing tips to astonish your editor:
Macro E’s think big. Bam!
They look at the piece’s structure, how the writing is organized and whether each section adds to your overall theme. They’re checking your tone to make sure the content speaks to your target audience in their language. Plus, they keep an eye on pacing so your points are made thoroughly without d-r-a-g-g-i-n-g.
Give your biggest points ample space and prominent placement. In journalistic language, don’t bury your lead.
Macroeditors have style—yours, that is. A great macroeditor recognizes when the writer’s style reigns over a “rule.” They don’t want to be accused of rewriting to their own tastes, so editors keep their hands off a writer’s idiosyncrasies when those unique writing habits work for the piece.
Take regional dialect, for instance; if you’re a southerner, y’all’s editor ought to let your twang shine now and then. Another example is the inspirational writer who wants all pronouns for God capitalized, even though the current rule of thumb is to lowercase them. And sentence fragments. Sometimes effective, right? A wise editor makes an exception.
But when you scribble flat prose lacking in style, your editor must work overtime to make sure your work has flare. Make sure you’re writing has the right amount of twinges and twangs of your unique style.
Macroeditors are your besties, in part, because they want you to look fabulous now and in the future. These are the guardians of your personal info.
They’re eyeing sensitive info you might not want made public—aka, they don’t want you to wake up to a bad case of the regrets. Expect them to second-guess you if something you’ve shared crosses the line, yes, that line, and could embarrass you or the people in your life.
Before submitting your work make sure you review private relationship details, money, tax troubles, and other red flags that might catch the macro E’s eye.
Related to number 3, remember that the responsibility rests on the writer to secure permission from copyright holders to borrow quotes or lyrics. A macroeditor will always ask if you acquired permission.
The editor will also guide the writer about which rights to petition for (i.e., Worldwide, digital and web, maximum print run for printed work, etc.).
A handy rule of thumb: skip the song lyrics—those are a legal dumpster fire.
The editor points out overuse and misuse of writing techniques such as:
And exclamation points!!!
Emphatics are intended to focus the attention of readers, but they should be pared down in published work.
Like the hub of the publication wheel, the macroeditor communicates between you, the writer, and the microeditors farther down the road. They check the copyedits and proofs to ensure nothing gets changed that they’ve already okay’d with the writer.
These are the guardians of the publishing galaxy.
Every. Chance. You. Get.
So follow these rules to save them time and make them love you back. And when all else fails, a Starbucks gift card and thank you notes is probably in order. I’ve never met an editor so frigid they couldn’t be thawed by a Pumpkin Spice Latte.
Jennifer Grant is an author and editor in the Chicago area. Mother of four children, she is author of five books including the forthcoming When Did Everybody Else Get So Old? More at jennifergrant.com
"Jonathan and Margaret are two of the best writing coaches in America, and I've learned much from them over the years. Their Write Brilliant program will help you grow deep roots and a wide reach. Do not wait to sign-up!"
– Gabe Lyons
Bestselling author of Good Faith and founder of Q
"I highly recommend Jonathan and Margaret's program for writers of any level!"
– Jennie Allen,
bestselling author of Nothing to Prove and founder of IF:Gathering
"The firehose of information I absorbed through Write Brilliant transformed the way I write. Jonathan and Margaret bring a combined breadth of knowledge and a straight-shooting style that helped me clarify my target audience, expand my platform, and get practical about what it takes to dedicate myself to my craft. I learned more in this one course than in all past conferences, books, blogs, and videos I’ve engaged. Write Brilliant is a one-stop-shop for taking your writing to the next level."
– September Vaudrey,
author of Colors of Goodbye
"In all my years of leading organizations, I've encountered dozens of how-to programs, but none of them has been more effective then this one. I should know. The Write Brilliant strategy gave me the boost of confidence I needed to create two books on leadership. Whether you want to author a book or just create a blog, make sure you don't miss this fantastic course."
– Brad Lomenick,
author of H3 Leadership and former director of Catalyst
In this week’s Write Brilliant Quick Tip, Margaret Feinberg talks about 3 main sources of discouragement in your writing and how to overcome them.
It’s easy to dismiss making resolutions especially if, like me, […]
In this week’s Write Brilliant Quick Tip, Margaret Feinberg talks […]